Question 1
The issue arising here is whether the insured-Steve was entitle to rely on the insurance policy he purchased to obtain indemnity after he misrepresented the material facts of the insured house. The focal point is whether Steve have constituted a violation of duty of disclosure and mis-presentation under Australian insurance laws. In Australian, the Insurance Act 1973 and Insurance Contracts Act 1984 are the main legislation relating to the body of law that mandates the insurance industry and insurance contracts, replenished by a series of other pieces of regulations legislated by the states, private code and case law. The duty of utmost good faith is one of the key principles in Australian Insurance Contract Act 19841 and have been established in the case of GIO Insurance Ltd vs Leighton Contactors Pty Ltd, which refers to all parties of an insurance contract should act in good faith, make a full and clear declaration of all relevant material facts in the insurance proposal2.
However, the Australian Insurance Contract Act 1984 provides a significant difference of duty of utmost good faith and duty of disclosure, which are two confusable concepts. The former one is set out in section 13 as a post-contractual obligation, while the latter one is regulated in section 21 as a pre-contractual obligation. Under Australian Insurance Contract Act 1984, Division 1, 2 and 3 of Part IV provides the issue of disclosure, mis-presentation and remedies for non-disclosure and mis-presentation3. The meaning of non-disclosure and mis-presentation are quite similar and sometimes even overlap that non-disclosure of certain fact may also cause a mis-presentation in such pact. Section 21 of the Australian Insurance Contract Act 1984 provides that insureds have been liable to disclose matters relevant to the risk insured. To be more specific, before the insurance contract is entered into, every relevant matters should be disclosed to insurer by insured, including "every matter that the insured knows to be a matter relevant to the decision of the insurer whether to accept the risk and, if so, on what terms; every matter that a reasonable person in the circumstances could be expected to know to be such a relevant matter"4. In Permanent Trustee Australia Ltd vs FAI General Insurance Co Ltd (in liq), the High Court of Australia ruled that the facts should be disclosed not only is "relevant to the decision of the insurer as to whether to accept the risk, and if so, on what terms", but also is the insured known to be relevant5.
Mis-presentation is governed by the section 26 of the Australian Insurance Contract Act 1984, which restrains the scope that an insurer are able to establish an actionable mis-presentation by an insured having occurred6. According to section 26(2), a false statement will not be considered as a mis-presentation unless its maker have known, or a reasonable person in the circumstance should know, that the statement would be treated as in relating to the decision of the insurer whether accept the risk7. In other words, an insurer is entitled to exempt from liability under the insurance contract if a mis-presentation of a material matter by the insured is confirmed and result in the formation of the insurance contract whether it is innocent or fraudulent. Moreover, section 23 of the Australian Insurance Contract Act 1984 provides the circumstance of where insured falsely answers an ambiguous question. Section 23 of the Act states that if the insured provides false information to the question, “a reasonable person in the circumstances would have understood the question to have the meaning that the person answering the question apparently understood it to have, that meaning shall be deemed to be the meaning of the question”8.
Backing to Steve’s case, in the property insurance relating to the house, because of different level of risk tolerance, the category of building materials is substantial factor that insurer will
Related Documents: Australian Insurance Law Case Study Essay
Intensive 24 5 General English Standard 20 5 Exam Preparation – IELTS 6 Course Progress 7 Completion of Course 18 Self Study 20 Student Services 21 Social Progam ACCOMMODATION 11 Your Homestay PRACTICAL INFORMATION 16 16 17 17 18 19 20 21 22 Insurance – OSHC Grievance Procedure Terms and Conditions Fire Procedure Medical Care Visas and Attendance Safety and the Law Postal Information Other Information LOCATIONS 24 Brisbane 25 Surfers Paradise 26 Melbourne 27 Sydney 1 COURSES…
International Journal of Finance & Banking Studies IJFBS Vol.3 No.1, 2014 ISSN: 2147-4486 available online at www.ssbfnet.com Indonesian And Australian Tax Policy Implementation In Food And Agriculture Industry Hanggoro Pamungkas a, Maya Safira Dewi b, Yunita Anwar c, Martin Surya Mulyadi d a,b,c,d Bina Nusantara University, KH Syahdan 9, Jakarta 11480, Indonesia Abstract Tax policy is one of the most important policy in consideration of investment development in certain industry. Research by…
Current strategy of a division of paramount Australian corporation (Wesfarmers) (Name) (University affiliation) Current strategy of a division of major Australian corporation (Wesfarmers) Wesfarmers is one of Australia’s oldest and most successful diversified companies. It founded in June 1914 as a small farmers' co-operative whose primary purpose was to provide services and rural commodities to Western Australia's agricultural population, Wesfamers commenced her trip to diversification…
SCOPE This policy applies to all international students undertaking a University of Canberra program of study in Australia. This includes students enrolled in a University of Canberra award program through the University of Canberra College. An international student is a student who: - Is not an Australian citizen - Does not hold a permanent resident visa - Does not hold a permanent Australian humanitarian visa - Is not a New Zealand citizen FEE CHARGES International student fees are made up…
The Report of Expansion Bank of Queensland Business in Thailand Analysis Song Wu 11/10/2012 Executive Summary: This article is one business investment report due to the requirement of Bank of Queensland Ltd. As the management…
02 May 14 Contract Law – Question and Suggested Answer applying IRAC to help with EC4003 Final Assessment When preparing for a law-based assessment here are a few pointers which students may find helpful. You will be given case studies well in advance of the assessment to enable you to identify and research the relevant legal issues. When analysing any law-based case study you may find it helpful to use the IRAC process (which can usually be found in module booklets and online via weblearn/Blackboard…
Dear X Thank you for your e-mail expressing interest in PhD studies in the School of Plant Biology/Institute of Agriculture/Oceans Institute at UWA. Please read through the information provided below. Unless you have already acquired a scholarship to fund the fees and stipend for your studies, or wish to self-fund your studies, you will need to apply for an IPRS through UWA, one of the other Australian government options listed below or scholarships from your home country government or other…
the structure, process and effectiveness of the governance of the organisation and make recommendations for appropriate improvements. Executive summary This report sets out to review corporate governance at a private company, namely, Paramount Insurance Company. The specific objectives were to identify the relevant codes the organisation follows, why they are important and review the structure, process and…
UNIT NAME: FORECAST INTERNATIONAL MARKET AND BUSINESS NEEDS TASK 1- Collect Market Intelligence REPORT. 1.INTRODUCTION- The objective of this report is to forecast international market and business needs throughout Australian Academy of Mentoring Coaching (AAMC) Training group. AAMC already expanded their operations overseas starting in India in 2009, currently (november 2013) they are stablished and expanding their business through the asian market. This means that AAMC should always make sure…
custom, rules, law, fairness, equality + justice, values and ethics Anarchy: The situation that exists in a society that does not have laws or state rule Custom: The collective habits, or traditions, that have been developed by a society over a long period of time Rules: The authoritative regulation of behaviour Fairness: The legitimate and proper conduct in the performance of an act or duty Equality: Suggests that everyone is treated the same. Formal equality occurs when the law provides that…