INTRODUCTION AND OVERVIEW
“Anytime, Anywhere” communications surmises AT&T’s strategic vision and represents a clear departure from the firms local phone and long-distance service provider roots.
AT&T’s continued diversification into several high tech equipment and service business lines clearly signals the realization that while it’s certainly the largest long-distance provider in the US, growth is slow, market share is eroding and profit margins are poor.
It is within this context that the opportunity to enter the fledgling cellular communications industry via the acquisition of McCaw presents itself. McCaw’s cellular network is now national in footprint and has access to largest potential subscriber base amongst competing firms (see Table A1 in Appendix). Moving into cellular represents domestic top line growth opportunities and an avenue to grow internationally – helping to fulfill the mandate of the board. While potential revenue synergies are attractive, the savings in local access fees (enabled by using McCaw’s network) is itself worth hundreds of millions annually. Cellular could bind and enhance the potential of many of AT&T’s other endeavours and provide the infrastructure to achieve its vision.
However timing is of the essence. Recent M&A activity signals that local phone companies are moving into the cellular sector and the likelihood of further competition with the advent of PCS is looming. McCaw is currently highly leveraged – which may challenge its growth- and recent talks indicate that at the very least there is a cursory interest in partnering. Presented herein is a report to AT&T’s board that incorporates several approaches in arriving at a valuation of McCaw and a negotiation strategy that addresses both pricing strategy and deal structure.
ASSUMPTIONS
While various assumptions in McCaw’s valuation are noted in the accompanying appendices, key assumptions worth highlighting are:
• The option to purchase the balance LIN shares will be exercised in 1995 (although some consideration in pricing is given to the possibility of McCaw selling its current shares). •
Only the cellular portion of the business is being modelled since that is of most importance to AT&T. McCaw cellular business represented 80% and 83% of total revenues in 1990 and 1991 respectively (according to the companies Annual Reports).
AT&T/McCaw Negotiation
Appendix A: Valuation Using Comparable Companies3
VALUATION
VALUATION 1: COMPARABLE COMPANIES
When compared to firms in the broad telecommunications industry using primarily market value- based metrics (i.e. market capitalization against revenues, book value and net income)1 McCaw generates an average valuation of $4.76 billion. See Appendix A for full valuation details. Revenue from the top 7 cellular firms in the US in 1991 ranged from
Vanguard’s $89 million to British Telecom’s (BT) $23.2 billion2 . McCaw, Air Touch and LIN followed BT with revenues of $1.36 billion, $782 million and $468 million respectively. The performance of the aforementioned firms was used a benchmark in McCaw’s valuation; however the wide spread in firm size and negative earnings posted by both LIN and Contel
(making P/E ratios unusable) renders the resultant valuation of $7.1 billion as a loose guideline at best.
Given recent acquisitions by Bell Atlantic and BellSouth, and AT&T’s own interest in the cellular sector a valuation of McCaw was also generated using comparable local phone and long-distance companies. 3 Performing comparables with GTE, MCI and Sprint in addition to the above produced separate valuations of McCaw each nearing $3.8 billion.
The arguably low valuations are a result of using ratios from these mature sectors and applying it to a growth sector that requires high
and he’s ten.” T, the main character is walking into school with her friends and Queen Bee L decides to embarrass her. Why, you may ask? Jealousy? Insecurity? Who knows? However, comments like that are the least of T’s worries as teen-on-teen conflict transforms into something more sinister: Cyber bullying. Up until her 17th birthday, T’s mum has been strict about her computer usage to the point that T’s friends remark that “she doesn’t even have the internet on her phone.” T is thrilled when…
Far More Than You Bargained for Picture this: you purchase a fake Gucci handbag in Los Angeles for a mere fifty dollars. The invisible, yet oh-so realistic price tag includes an extensive list of crimes and obscenities that greatly outweighs those fifty dollars. Counterfeit goods are far more than cheap imitations of luxury brand items in the realm of fashion. When one purchases such articles, he or she supports indecencies such as child labor and terrorism, as well as countless additional dreadful…
T-mall’s Campaign Plan Chiwei Wu Fangbing Lu Guanhua Li Ke Xu Wu Di Yue Wan MBA 529 Instructor: Gregg Arnold T-mall Introduction T-mall.com is a business to customer market place which is owned by Alibaba Group. At the begging, it was introduced via Taobao as “Taobao Mall” in 2008. While T-mall became an independent company after Alibaba reorganized Taobao into three companies in 2011, including Taobao Mall (a C2C online shopping platform), eTao (an online price comparison search tool)…
expanded their product line to include replicas of authentic artifacts that would be hard to come by. These products are produced by native people or qualified craftspeople who are well trained. This ensures that the artifacts are not going to be fake or just versions that are not substantial in quality. Doing this ensures that the customers get a high quality product. W – Weaknesses One very serious weakness that Sorzal Distributors is facing, is that the authentic artifact supply is at an…
this day, 20% of Americans believe that the moon landing was a hoax. However, those people seem to miss that the moon hoax would have been impossible. Some people say that in 1969, it was impossible to send someone to the moon but it was possible to fake it on video. This is in fact, the exact opposite of what is true. Since the 1920s, engineers were busy trying to improve liquid fuel rockets. They wanted to go to the outer space. By 1943, there was already a fully functional rocket that could enter…
The rise of the internet has changed our lives irrevocably. Over the past two decades, the world has become more connected than ever before thanks to social media websites like Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram. They have allowed us to share our thoughts and our daily activities with friends and followers all over the world, creating a sort of global culture. The internet has played a large role in the breaking down of barriers and the normalizing and acceptance of certain things and people that would…
Property Crime One day john and his friend jack was driving around in the car. They were very board. Jack said we should go on a cross country on a road trip. Then john said we don't have any money or a relibel car. So they both decide that they need some money and a new car. So jack said how about we go steel some and then john agreed. So they drove to this very nice rich neighbor hood thinking that they will get lost of cash. So john and jack got mask and went up to the windows bust them out and found the…
Currently, Intel is directing its strategy toward specialty chips for products other than computers, such as autos, security, http://textflow.mheducation.com/parser.php?secload=2&fake&print 1/3 6/8/2015 IEB Wireframe cell phones, air controls. Another goal is to reduce project cycle times. Intel, NEC, General Electric, and AT&T have reduced their cycle times by 20–50 percent. Projects and project management play the key role in supporting strategic goals. It is vital for project managers to think and act strategically…
11/11/14 The Moon Landing Throughout NASA’s history people have started questioning if Apollo 11 actually landed on the moon or not. There are plenty of people that seem to believe that the United States’ moon landing has been fake and everything that we thought we saw was a big fake. In fact up to 20% of all Americans believe that Neil Armstrong’s famous quote carries no weight (Fox, Paragraph 2). “One Small Step for Man, One Giant Leap for Mankind” These people believe that the United States…
Vegas postulated to be ‘hyperreal’? Furthermore why is it that so many people in the world want to visit Las Vegas, and people return back to Las Vegas year after year, even though we all believe the city, and everything within it, is superficial and fake? Perhaps it is to do with nostalgia, or the fact that Las Vegas is very good at being a themed illusion which puts everyone into a trance and make them believe they are in fantasyland? Why is Las Vegas the way that it is and has been, and will it be…