Freedom of Choice
Do we have the right to decide whether we live or die? When asked in a simple context the answer seems easy but add illness, doctors and family to the mix and things aren’t as clear cut. Does a patient who is suffering from pain and illness have the right to end their life with the help of a doctor? Answering that question is a little more difficult as ethics and legalities come into play. When discussing the everlasting debate over legalizing the practice of physician- assisted suicide I believe every patient has the right to choose between life and death if they can no longer benefit from standard methods of treatment. In their book, Physician- Assisted Suicide -The Anatomy of a Constitutional Law Issue, Susan Behuniak and Arthur Svenson define Physician Assisted Suicide (PAS) as a medical practice that involves a physician assisting a terminally ill, competent adult in dying by writing a prescription for a lethal dose of a drug that will be self administered by the patient. (Behuniak & S.M, 2003, p. 1) This is not to be confused with euthanasia in which the doctor would administer the lethal drug to end the patient’s life, a practice that is illegal in the United States. In PAS a patient would be prescribed a medication in which they would physically take themselves after undergoing the proper evaluation as outlined by state legislature and receiving clearance. This decision can only be made by the patient, not the family, not the doctor. Currently only Oregon, Washington and Montana have legislation in favor of PAS but the debate continues worldwide about what constitutes ending a life and is it ethical for a physician to assist in doing so. Before Montana had legislation in favor of Physician- Assisted Suicide, Robert Baxter, a Montana native, was a perfect example of why everyone should have the right to choose. At age 76, Baxter suffered from lymphatic leukemia and after months of suffering, wanted to die. This was prior to Montana passing any legislation in favor of PAS and therefore Baxter’s doctors did what they were obligated to do, they kept him alive until he passed away on his own. An article written by Kirk Johnson for the New York Times, reports that Baxter claimed his rights under the Montana Constitution were violated when the doctor refused to help him die. (Johnson, 2009) The debate began and in 2010 Montana became the third state to legalize Physician Assisted Suicide with the grounds that the decision is that of the individual, not the government. A common argument against PAS legislation is that doctors are supposed to save lives and it is unethical for them to participate in an act that opposes what they are supposed to stand for. However, when I think of a doctor I think of someone who will take care of me and have my best interest, even if that interest is dying when all other treatment is exhausted. Society, including nurses and doctors, need to have respect for autonomy. The decision about when enough is enough is personal and can only be made by the patient. A person who is terminally ill deserves to make choices for themselves as they would if they were well. The right to be independent and make choices shouldn’t end when you enter the hospital. Legalizing Physician Assisted Suicide doesn’t mean that anyone who is treated by a physician can request aid in ending their life. Behuniak and Svenson outline the Oregon Death with Dignity Act which describes the process a patient must undergo before they are even given the choice of PAS. For example, a patient must undergo counseling to ensure that they are in a mental state to make the decision, they must be informed about their prognosis and risk of taking medication and they must have a terminal disease that will produce death within six months. (Behuniak & S.M, 2003, p. 29) If a patient has been properly informed and is mentally stable when making the decision then doctors or legislation don’t have the
Kylie Brown Period 1 English H March 5, 2015 Should Assisted Suicide be legalized? Every year in the United States, a little over one million people die of a terminal illness that they know will not be cured and they will die. Many of these desperate patients go through a long and traumatic experience that drains everything they have, emotionally and physically. While coming to the end of their life, they are in excruciating pain and there is nothing to do but sit and wait. In four states, Euthanasia…
A. English 104 - 407 25 October 2014 Assisted Suicide The concept of assisted suicide may seem twisted to those who do not understand. It may seem wrong for someone to end the life of another person upon their request. The problem with this is that some cannot bring death upon themselves due to disease or illness that prevents them from doing so. These situations are either fixed or prolonged with or without the practice of assisted suicide. Assisted suicide is brought on by a lethal drug, gun,…
The idea of assisted suicide is a very, very slippery slope in my opinion - not that I don't approve of people having the right to make their own choices as to when they've had enough, but it could lead to lawmakers and other people in positions of power deciding that people with certain conditions or with a certain degree of severity are not worthy of being alive based on some subjective measure of "quality of life". We've already seen it, with disabled people (particularly developmentally disabled…
certain issues. I am going to discuss the ethical issues with physician assisted suicide and how negative it can be. Some physicians may think that they are helping their patients by doing this but it is wrong are numerous different ways and I will share several of them in this essay. There are ethical issues all around us and one particular that I personally find disturbing that happens all the time is physician assisted suicide. This is something that is downright despicable to help take a human…
Thinking Ethically: Who Gains from Employee Development Jessica Berry Kaplan University AB203: Human Resources Management – 02 Jennifer Bryant May 23, 2014 In simple terms, training and development refers to the imparting of specific skills, abilities and knowledge to an employee. A formal definition of training & development is… it is any attempt to improve current or future employee performance by increasing an employee’s ability to perform through learning, usually by changing…
Pro Choice: Physician Assisted Suicide Assisted suicide can date it origins back to Roman times before the christian overhaul, where doctors gave suffering patients a fatal poison. With the new coming of religon throughout the world the act of “assisted suicide” was deemed a sin. Not until recently in the 20th century has this issue been a frontpage headline that is causing severe controversy. The arguments for and against loosly include that it is murder offends many religons and is inhuman. Support…
The Legalization of Assisted Suicide Assisted suicide is a topic that has caused much controversy as to whether it is a humane way to end a terminally ill person’s life or if it is a violation of the basic laws of medicine and devalues a person’s life. I personally believe that assisted suicide should be legalized in all states because every person has the right to decide what is best for his or her own life whether that decision is to live or to die. Assisted suicide is when a physician does…
Physician Assisted Suicide Itay Stawski ITT Technical Institute EN 1420 Professor Jeremy Pilarski November 10 2014 The Right to die debate; is the common name of this current issue. It’s legal in the state of Oregon since 1998. Since then more than 341 terminally ill people have taken advantage of it to hasten their deaths. According to Humphry (2013, September) “The Washington Death with Dignity Act, Initiative 1000, codified as RCW 70.245, passed on November 4, 2008” http://finalexit…
can die with dignity rather than becoming a shell of their former selves. Without PAS people may commit suicide in a messy, horrifying or traumatic manor. Physician assisted suicide (PAS) is not for everyone, but for someone who wants to end their life because of a terminal debilitating illness, they should have that option with the help of a knowledgeable physician. Physician assisted suicide is defined by the American Medical Association as “when a physician facilitates a patient’s death by providing…
Name: Marva Dyer Date: June 3, 2008 Class: PHI1103 Word Count: 1225 Topic: Physician Assisted Suicide 1. Introduction and Thesis Chronic and life-limiting illness can also make a person feel like they have lost all control of their lives. The body isn’t doing what it should and there’s no way to stop it. Physician-assisted suicide (PAS) may feel like a way to regain some of that control. If they can’t control the illness, they can at least control how they die. Quality of life is the…