The Israel-Egypt Peace Treaty of 1979: A Balance of Peace and Power in the Middle East
The Arab-Israeli conflict, initiated over one-hundred years ago and still continuing, has confounded both policy-makers and citizens; despite the best efforts of foreign leaders, only one substantial accord has materialized in the decades of negotiations: the Israel-Egypt peace treaty of 1979. Foreign policy can’t be viewed in a vacuum; rather, each country must be viewed as a nation with legitimate historical and political aspirations. When evaluating foreign policy, there are two methods of analysis: one is to concentrate on the output and documents produced by working backwards, deducing the intents of the various leaders from the end result; the other method is to focus on the politics of decision making, viewing foreign policy as a result of individual political aims. The first approach focuses on the primary sources, while the other concentrates on the parties themselves. In this paper, I will give a comprehensive background of Israel-Egypt relations, and utilize the two forms of analyses to deduce what the goals of each party were at the time the treaty was signed, and use the lens of hindsight to evaluate whether their goals were met.
The dispute over the territory called Palestine began relatively recently. Palestinian Arabs had lived as impoverished peasants under corrupt, continuous Ottoman rule for centuries; political identification as a Palestinian within the broad current of Arab nationalism only began at the beginning of the 20th century, as living conditions in Palestine slowly began to improve. Meanwhile, Zionists had been organizing small but steady waves of immigration into Palestine as early as 1882. Arab resentment toward the Zionists emerged due to economic and political concerns: the local Palestinian populations were justifiably afraid that the Jewish population would monopolize trade or provide unwanted economic competition, while the Arab nationalists were anxious that Zionism not interfere with their own political aspirations.
Egypt, in contrast to Palestine, was the leader of the Arab world. In the 1800s, Egypt, under the leadership of Muhammad Ali, began a campaign of “defensive modernization”; that is, an importation of military and economic principles of the West in an effort to rejuvenate the Arab world and its culture. The khedives (rulers) who succeeded Ali continued his campaign of modernization by constructing new facilities; the Suez Canal, an important position in trade between Europe and the Far East, was constructed in 1869. However, this modernization invited the imperialism that Egypt sought to avoid; in 1883, Egypt became a “veiled protectorate” (an unofficial colonial dependency), and on the eve of World War I, a formal British protectorate was established until the Egyptian Revolution of 1952.
During the War, Britain issued three conflicting statements with regard to Palestine: the McMahon letters, the Sykes-Picot agreement, and the Balfour Declaration, the various explanations of Britain’s strategic motives in the region, however, did nothing to ease Palestinian fears of renewed imperialism. Indeed, their fears were justified; Britain, acting under the authority of Article 22 of the Covenant of the League of Nations, established a mandate in Palestine. The years leading up until 1948 were marked by riots and subsequent commissions of inquiry, the most notable being the 1947 U.N. Partition Plan.
Currents of Egyptian nationalism emerged as a response to the perceived disadvantages of colonialism and the widespread criticism of the inept and corrupt regime in Egypt. Some of these currents played on popular anti-Zionist tendencies; Egypt’s historically excellent relations with Palestine were ruptured by the Zionist presence. These currents resulted in a deposition of the corrupt and inept Wafd regime; on “Black Saturday”, January 26, 1952, large-scale rioting broke out in Cairo, and a
Related Documents: 1979 Israeli-Egypt Peace Treaty Essay
The Effectiveness of the Arab and Israeli Peace Initiatives No peace with Israel; no recognition of Israel; no negotiations with Israel. Major concerns of Israelis (since 1948): - security of the state - refusal of the Arab states to acknowledge Israel's right to exist There were significant developments between 1973 and 1979. Following the 1973 war, Israel realised it urgently needed to explore ways of achieving peace with its neighbours as the balance of power in the Middle East had…
Arab nation The Israeli! - 1948-9 War confirmed the dangers of disunity! - The Arab states: Egypt, Iraq, Jordan, Lebanon, and Syria declared war on the emerging state of Israel, but fought as separate countries that pursued rather than a unified state! - Had They Been United, This Attack Would Have Been More Successful As They Would Stand A Better Chance Of Defeating Their Enemy! - This defeat was a good reason for the arabs to form a united force! - 1956: French, British and Israeli armies were forced…
between Anwar Sadat of Egypt and Menachem Begin of Israel, mediated by Jimmy Carter, which outlined a framework for establishing peace in the Middle East. This agreement was the basis of the peace treaty between Israel and Egypt signed in Washington • Oslo Accords: agreement between Israel and the Palestinians which included security arrangements and partial Israeli withdrawal from the West Bank and the Gaza Strip • 6 Day War: tension between Arabs and Israeli erupted into a brief…
Knesset. This unprecedented olive branch, offered to a country upon which he had ordered a surprise attack just three years before, set the stage for a peace process that would culminate sixteen months later in the Egypt-Israeli Peace Treaty. The pivotal point in this process came in September 1977 when President Carter brought Sadat and Israeli Prime Minister Menachem…
DEATH DATE: October 06, 1981 PLACE OF BIRTH: Mit Ab al-Kawm, Al-Minufiyyah governorate, Egypt PLACE OF DEATH: Cairo, Egypt FULL NAME: Muhammad Anwar el-Sadat AKA: Anwar el-Sadat AKA: Anwar Sadat AKA: Muhammad Anwar al-Sadat AKA: Anwar al-Sadat AKA: Anwar El Sadat BEST KNOWN FOR Anwar el-Sadat was the one-time president of Egypt (1970-1981) who shared the 1978 Nobel Peace Prize for establishing peace agreements with Israel. QUIZ Think you know about Biography? Answer questions and…
Terry Sales Ideas are a blessing and a curse, they can build wonderful things or can destroy that very same thing. Most of the time different ideas can reach a compromise, but when neither ideas gives way nor both sides fill strongly about it this leads to conflict or in this cause war. This belief or, ideologies, was a driving force between the capitalism of The United States…
of the third millennium BCE. In addition to successful agriculture and river management, such as the creation of irrigation canals, the Sumerians developed a form of writing known as cuneiform. Scribes used this form of writing to set down laws, treaties, and important social and religious customs; soon the use of cuneiform spread over the trade routes to many other parts of the region. Sumerians also developed a twelve-month calendar and math system. They were polytheistic, and they built temples…
movement throughout much of the Arab and Muslim worlds,[8] and is considered more powerful than the Lebanese Army. Al Qaida- a global militant Islamist organization founded by Osama Bin Laden in Pakestine; Groups in Afganistan, Iraq, Saudi Arabia, Egypt, Nigeria, Pakestine, Somalia, Syria, Yemen; operates as a network comprising both a multinational stateless army and a radical Muslim movement calling for global Jihad and a strict interpretation of Sharia law. Red Brigades- is a Marxist- Leninist…
Cold War Definitions 1.North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO): An association of European and North American countries. Formed in 1949 for defense against the Soviet Union after World War II. NATO is a treaty between the 28 countries who are sworn to respond with help, by political or military means, if a member was attack by an external party . 2.Warsaw Pact: A post-World War II military alliance involving the USSR and the Soviet-bloc countries of Bulgaria, Czechoslovakia, East Germany…
Unit 9 Organizing Principle The cold war led the United States to pursue an ambivalent policy of confrontation, negotiation and prevention maintenance I. The Kennedy Administration A. Election of 1960 1. Republicans nominate Richard Nixon, Eisenhower’s VP a. Nixon is viewed as tough on communism and experienced in politics and foreign affairs 2. Democrats nominate John Kennedy (Mass) after a hard primary fight with Lyndon B. Johnson of Texas a. Major weaknesses included inexperience, lack of…